Hulu’s mystery thriller Paradise continues to build suspense as the stakes rise with every episode. In Episode 4, the story tells about the complex dynamics of the underground city, blending the everyday lives of its citizens with the dark mysteries lurking beneath its idyllic surface. Here's a spoiler-filled glimpse into the episode and what fans can anticipate next.
Spoilers: The Carnival and the Investigation
Episode 4 begins with the citizens of Paradise preparing for their annual carnival, a celebration designed to lift spirits and preserve a sense of normalcy in the post-apocalyptic haven. Vibrant decorations line the streets, and the event promises fun, music, and games—a much-needed distraction from the unease triggered by President Cal Bradford’s shocking murder. For most of the residents, the carnival is a symbol of hope and unity. But for Xavier Collins and Billy, it becomes the backdrop to their relentless investigation.
As the festivities unfold, Xavier and Billy dig deeper into the web of secrets surrounding the President’s death. The tension between the two continues to simmer, especially as Xavier grows increasingly skeptical of Billy’s behavior on the night of the murder. Billy’s admission of negligence in Episode 3 still lingers, but Xavier can’t help but wonder if there’s more to the story.
Paradise’s Carnival: A Celebration with Hidden Agendas

The annual carnival offers a fascinating contrast to the grim realities plaguing Paradise. It is a rare moment of joy in the underground city, with colorful parades and cultural showcases. Yet, even amidst the festivities, unease is palpable. Gabriella Tarabi, the city’s enigmatic therapist, makes an appearance and subtly observes the citizens' behavior, suggesting she’s aware of more than she lets on, leaving viewers to question her true motivations.
Samantha Redmond, the influential architect behind Paradise, uses the carnival as an opportunity to address the crowd, emphasizing unity and resilience. However, her polished speech raises more questions than answers. Is her focus on maintaining peace merely a facade to cover up deeper secrets about Paradise’s leadership? Her interactions with Xavier grow tense, adding twist to their strained dynamic.
The Investigation Heats Up

Meanwhile, Xavier uncovers a critical lead—a potential connection between Cal’s murder and the mysterious number “812092” found on the cigarette in Episode 3. Xavier begins to suspect that the number might be tied to Paradise’s early days, possibly referencing a flight Samantha organized to bring select individuals to safety. This revelation could implicate Samantha or others in power, hinting at corruption and cover-ups within Paradise's leadership.
Billy, on the other hand, follows a different lead. His interrogation of Jane, the security officer who was also on duty the night of the murder, reveals a hidden truth about her involvement. Jane finally admits to seeing someone suspicious near Cal’s quarters that night but hesitates to report it out of fear of being blamed. Her confession adds more suspects to the growing list and raises doubts about her credibility.
The episode might also feature a chilling moment as Xavier stumbles upon an old recording from Cal, seemingly meant for him. In the message, Cal cryptically warns Xavier about “the truth buried in Paradise” and urges him to protect the city at all costs.
What to Expect Next

As Paradise moves forward, fans can anticipate more twists and revelations. Here’s what Episode 4 sets the stage for:
- Escalating Tensions Between Xavier and Samantha
Xavier’s growing suspicions of Samantha will likely drive the next phase of the investigation. As he pieces together the significance of Cal’s warning, Samantha’s role in Paradise’s creation and governance could come under scrutiny, leading to explosive confrontations. - The Carnival as a Distraction
The carnival might not be as innocent as it seems. Samantha or Gabriella could orchestrate it as a deliberate diversion to shift attention away from the murder investigation. The vibrant celebration could mask darker plots unfolding behind the scenes. - New Suspects and Hidden Alliances
Jane’s confession introduces fresh suspects, and the fractured trust within Paradise’s security team raises the stakes. Could someone on the inside be working against Xavier? Moreover, Gabriella’s cryptic behavior suggests that she might play a pivotal role in unraveling—or protecting—the truth. - The Deeper Mysteries of Paradise
Could the murder be connected to a long-buried conflict or betrayal during Paradise’s creation? As Xavier digs into these clues, viewers can expect shocking truths that redefine their understanding of Paradise. - An Unpredictable Power Struggle
With Cal’s death, Paradise is on the brink of political upheaval. Samantha may need to assert her authority to maintain order, but cracks in her leadership could spark rebellion among the citizens or even within her inner circle.
Conclusion
As Xavier and Billy dig deeper, the stakes rise, and the line between ally and enemy grows blurrier. Each revelation makes it clear that Paradise is a ticking time bomb waiting to explode. Fans can only brace themselves for what promises to be a thrilling journey into the heart of mystery and survival.
Read more: Paradise Season 1, Episode 3: Secrets and Survival