As The Buccaneers Season 2 barrels into its halfway mark, we’re left in the wreckage of Episode 3—hearts broken, truths unburied, and one determined woman racing across Europe in pursuit of the man she never stopped loving. With Nan in flight, Theo in crisis, Lizzy caught in a confusing emotional whirlwind, and everyone else tangled in their own webs of regret and longing, Episode 4 has a heavy burden to carry—and we can’t wait to see what it delivers.
What’s next? Expect fireworks, fractures, and maybe even a few redemptions. Let’s consider some theories and educated guesses about what might unfold in Episode 4 of The Buccaneers.
Nan’s Italian Gamble: Will Guy Still Be Waiting?
At the end of Episode 3, Nan made the most defiant choice of her life: she left the castle and set out for Italy, guided not just by letters she was never meant to find, but by the raw pulse of unfinished love. But here’s the big question: Will Guy still be there… and will he still want her?
Let’s not forget Guy has been licking his wounds in Italy for a while now, finding laughter (and maybe a spark?) with Jinny, who seems to have carved out a quiet little life alongside him. The food fight and easy friendship hinted at something more, even if it was fleeting. If Nan arrives, only to find Jinny and Guy entangled in a new chapter, will her fairytale reunion collapse before it starts?
One possibility is that Guy, heartbroken but loyal, has been waiting all along. Another, more gut-wrenching theory? He’s moved on—or at least tried to—and Nan’s sudden appearance threatens the peace he’s begun to build. Episode 4 could be the reckoning: a choice between past and present, between what was and what could be.
The Dowager’s Dilemma
Episode 3 gave us a surprising amount of depth from the Dowager Duchess. Once the master puppeteer behind every calculated move, she’s now being confronted with the cost of her ambition, most notably, in Nan. When Hector’s father told her that Nan reflects the life she once forfeited, it seemed to rattle something deep inside her.
So what’s next for the Dowager? In Episode 4, we may see a woman at a crossroads: does she continue protecting a crumbling institution, or does she help set Nan free, even if it means admitting her role in the tragedy? Her rekindled connection with Hector’s father may serve as both mirror and motivator; there’s still a chance for her to undo the damage—or at least soften it. But will pride get in the way?
Lizzy’s Emotional Entanglement
Poor Lizzy. One moment, she’s being proposed to by sweet, dependable Hector; the next, she’s reeling from Theo’s complicated compliments and awkward apologies. While Theo insists she deserves better than Hector, we can’t help but sense something murkier at play. Is he trying to protect her, or is there something he’s not saying, like feelings?
In Episode 4, we could see Lizzy grappling with real confusion. Does she go forward with Hector—the man who’s offered her stability and admiration, or does she pause to explore a deeper emotional pull with Theo, who might be as lost as she is? It’s dangerous territory, and one false move could blow up three hearts instead of two.
There’s also the looming guilt: if Lizzy keeps quiet about Nan’s destination, it could fracture her relationship with Theo forever. And if she does tell him, will she be pushing him back into Nan’s arms, just as he might be seeing Lizzy in a new light?
New Alliances, New Possibilities
After their heart-to-heart in Episode 3, it feels like Conchita and Cora are entering a new phase in their sisterhood. Cora, for once, seemed to absorb something deeper than her usual cynicism—perhaps even hope. And with the mysterious man in yellow socks still fresh in our minds, Episode 4 might push Cora into uncharted territory: genuine romantic curiosity.
Expect her to explore her softer side more, maybe even run into the yellow-sock stranger again. Could he be more than a symbol? Could he be a love interest? Cora finding love would be a twist we didn’t expect—but might desperately need.
Meanwhile, Conchita has her hands full managing everyone’s drama, but perhaps she’ll finally get a storyline of her own outside of the marriage counsellor. A scandal? A secret? A surprise pregnancy? Let’s not rule anything out.
Theo’s Breaking Point—and a New Path?
Now that Theo knows his mother orchestrated his marriage, not Nan, what comes next for him? He’s angry, bruised, and embarrassed—but the narrative is shifting. We could see him experience a full character arc in Episode 4: from vengeful victim to humbled man seeking amends.
His interactions with Lizzy might deepen. His search for Nan could begin. Or—and here’s a wild theory—what if he starts to unravel the entire institution himself? If the Duchess won’t dismantle the legacy of control, perhaps her son will. That could set up a fascinating rift in the family and a redefinition of power.
Will Secrets Explode?
Let’s not forget the dozens of secrets still floating around: the hidden letters, the forced marriage, Theo’s feelings, Lizzy’s conflicted heart, Jinny’s new role in Italy. Episode 4 feels like detonating one or all of these storylines.
If Nan arrives in Italy and discovers that Jinny withheld letters or feelings, expect fireworks. If Theo tries to find Nan and stumbles upon Lizzy’s secrecy, trust may be broken. If Guy is truly conflicted, we might see him torn between two women, two futures.
Whatever happens, Episode 4 promises to be the turning point, the moment when choices are made, masks fall, and no one walks away clean.
My Thoughts
Episode 3 ended with a woman in a carriage and a castle full of ghosts. Episode 4 will be the confrontation. The moment past love meets present pain. The season’s theme—women reclaiming their voices—is building to a crescendo. Who will fall apart, and who will finally break free?
One thing’s certain: The Buccaneers have stopped playing by the rules.
And the real battle?
It’s just getting started.
Read more: The Buccaneers episode 7
