Kat and Jacob Face a Difficult Decision
The episode opens with Kat and Jacob sitting in front of the burned ruins of Elijah’s home. The weight of their predicament is heavy: only one of them can return home, as Elijah needs help. Jacob, with a resigned yet understanding look, insists that Kat should stay. She has unfinished business with Thomas, and it’s something she cannot ignore. Despite the painful reality, Jacob reassures Kat that she needs to see this through, even if it means parting ways once again.
Elliot’s Disappointment
Back in the present, Elliot’s face falls when he learns that Kat is seeking help from Thomas. His disappointment is palpable, and it’s clear that Elliot is struggling with Kat’s continued connection to the past, he wonders if she will ever truly return to him or if her heart will always remain in another time.
Del’s Inner Turmoil and Alice’s Mission
Del is ready to rid herself of Colton’s lingering presence, tossing out his old belongings. Yet, something holds her back. Instead of letting go completely, she urges Alice to return to 1974 and seek out answers. Her own memories of that time are distorted beyond recognition, and she hopes Alice can piece together the truth. Del’s desperation is evident, and she struggles to reconcile her past grief with the present.
Jacob’s Research on Wildfires
Meanwhile, Jacob is engrossed in online research about wildfires, discovering that fire damage can taint vines for years, rendering wine undrinkable. The implications of this knowledge will likely play a role in the vineyard’s future. As he pieces together historical data, a newfound determination sparks within him, suggesting he may have a plan to change things in ways no one expects.
A Harsh Reality Check for Thomas and Kat
Kat and Thomas share a tense conversation. “We’ve been through dark times before, you and I,” Kat tells him. But luck runs out. The fire was a wake-up call—fate isn’t something you can cheat forever. Thomas expresses his concern, admitting that he would never know if something were to happen to Kat in her time. The uncertainty weighs heavily on both of them. The depth of their love is undeniable, but so is the impossibility of their situation.
A Metallic Discovery
Elliot, in the present, makes a curious discovery inside the old clock. He retrieves something metallic—its significance remains unknown for now. As he examines it, a wave of recognition crosses his face, hinting at a link between past and present yet to be revealed.
Jacob’s Discomfort at the Vineyard
Jacob begins working with Lewis at the vineyard, an act that echoes Port Haven’s history of families working together. Lewis is pleased, but Jacob can barely hide his disdain. His eyes darken as he glances at the fuel tank—what is he planning? The tension builds as Jacob wrestles with emotions that seem to be leading him down a dark path.
Evie’s Excitement and a New Opportunity
Back in 1974, Alice returns to an overjoyed Evie. Meanwhile, Colton receives big news: a producer loves his demo and wants him—and Alice—to come to San Francisco. Evie is thrilled, ready to embrace the adventure as Colton’s biggest supporter. For Colton, it’s a new path, one that he hopes will lead to Delilah. The excitement is infectious, but under the surface, unspoken fears linger.
Alice’s Hesitation
Alice considers joining Colton on the trip, but Evie holds her back. She wants this road trip to bring her closer to Colton. Alice, however, is distant. Evie notices and challenges her: dreams matter. A passing stranger even quotes T.S. Eliot, reminding Alice of the roads not taken. Life is too short for regrets. As the weight of her choices looms, Alice begins to question where her journey will ultimately lead her.
Susanna’s Scheme
In a different storyline, Susanna confides in Kat about her book. She knows she’s not safe—whether Cyrus lives or dies, she’s vulnerable. She needs to secure her future and suggests having Cyrus change his will to leave everything to her instead of his sons. The desperation in her plan speaks volumes about her reality. She refuses to be a victim of circumstance and is determined to rewrite her own fate.
A Desperate Moment for Colton
Alice finds Colton in a vulnerable state, seemingly on the verge of jumping. She pretends not to notice, but the moment is heavy. Meanwhile, Cyrus has suffered irreversible damage from the smoke—his larynx is destroyed, and he may never speak again. The tragedy of it all adds tension to an already fragile situation.
The Truth About the Pond
Colton opens up about the pond and his grandmother’s warnings. He had promised never to enter it, but fate intervened when he had to save Evie. Later, when he tried again, he ended up in 1814, using Jasper’s folk songs to teach the past about potatoes and rye. But breaking the rules had consequences—when he jumped again, he found himself in 1816, witnessing the unintended fallout of his actions. Now, the pond no longer works for him, a reality Alice doesn’t contradict. The burden of time travel weighs heavily on them both.
Susanna Takes Control
Determined to change the course of history, Susanna declares that she will be Cyrus’s voice, running Port Haven as she sees fit. He has no choice but to agree; her ambition is boundless, and her actions suggest she’s willing to go to any length to solidify her power.
A Proposal and a Heartbreaking Goodbye
Upon returning home, Colton finds Delilah waiting and proposes instantly. Alice watches from a distance, heartbroken. Meanwhile, Del reflects on her past losses, particularly her parents’ reaction to losing their wealth—they became unrecognizable, even selling her horse without letting her say goodbye. The weight of the past continues to shape the present, leaving lingering wounds.
Thomas and Kat’s Final Goodbye
Thomas asks Kat what their future holds. She doesn’t know. He once tried to reach her in the future, but the pond wouldn’t let him. If they were to pursue this, she would have to leave her entire life behind. He would never ask her to do that.
Kat recalls the saying: people come into your life for a reason, a season, or a lifetime. Thomas was not just a season—he was a reason. He made her realize what she wants from love: unwavering support, passion, and a partner who challenges her.
Thomas acknowledges their fate. He plans to leave on a ship bound for New York. “Fare thee well, My Thomas,” Kat says, tears streaming down her face. The finality of their goodbye lingers in the air.
Jacob’s Troubling Actions
Back in the present, Jacob is snooping around Elliot’s fireplace. Elliot, catching him in the act, has one demand—he wants Jacob to take him back to 1816. The implications of this request remain unclear.
A Bittersweet Reunion
Kat reassures Elijah that everything will be fine, but deep down, she is uncertain. Overcome with emotion, she breaks down. Just then, Elliot appears. Their eyes meet, and there’s a shift—she realizes how amazing he truly is.
Thomas, not too far away, shares a knowing glance with Elliot. It’s as if they’re passing the torch, an acknowledgment of something unspoken.
Caught on Camera
As the screen fades, we see that everything has been recorded on camera, setting up the next episode for a fierce confrontation. The stakes have never been higher, and the secrets of the past are finally on the verge of being revealed.
Read more: The Way Home Season 3
